Reputation risk 1. The RepTrak Company Example 1: Facebook. We quantify this intangible concept; monitor, measure, and manage it. This view has been gradually changing because it is increasingly clear that reputation is critical to the viability of a Unlike other risks that banks have to manage — credit, market, operational, liquidity, etc. Be reputation-ready to lower your company’s reputation risk. This page was last edited on 6 December 2020, at 00:39. Reputation is all about engendering trust. Reputation risk is any threat to your company's good name. These companies are reputation-ready. REPUTATION RISKAlso known as the Cinderella Asset!Michel RochetteMay 9 2007 Enterprise Risk Advisory, LLC You just clipped your first slide! Reputational risk has traditionally been seen as an outcome of other risks and not necessarily a standalone risk. Let’s start by defining what reputation or reputational risk is. Many theorists have proposed ways to manage reputational risk effectively. In such an age, reputation risk acts as an amplifier of your underlying risks – and if you are able to know and prepare for your risks you can also manage reputation opportunity and value creation. Reputational risk is the possibility that an organization's brand will be damaged. Toping the list are risks related to ethics and integrity, such as fraud, bribery, and corruption. Bank reputational risk is the risk of loss of reputation. Online reputation management is defined by search engine results, ranking consumer reviews, social media comments, articles, and press. @melanielobue In researching for this article, I have read a large volume of materials concerning reputational risk. Henry Ristuccia, global leader, Governance, Risk and Compliance Services, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, discusses why reputational risk requires a fundamentally different approach from traditional risk management practices and steps organizations … It does take time, effort, and dollars. Reputation risk management may be dependent on the location of a company as opinions about reputation risks differ significantly in the United States and in Europe. Here are the basics which apply to any form of entity – including large … Fast enough, the Kodak’s reputation became Melanie LoBue  In some cases, a decline in reputation can result in large financial losses stemming from difficulty raising capital, loss of sales and increased costs such as fines or legal fees.The following are a few examples of reputational risks. It’s no wonder that reputation is commonly referred to as a company’s most valuable asset. No. Eighty-seven percent of the executives we surveyed rate reputation risk as “more important” or “much more important,” and 88% say they are explicitly focusing on reputation risk However, extreme cases may lead to bankruptcy (as in the case of Arthur Andersen). Take for example Deutsche Bank’s definition of reputational risk. Consistent assessment of a company’s reputation, creating strategies and protocols to deal with external risks, while also improving internal policies and processes are all part of a sound risk management plan. A phone recording of the event went viral. 617-758-0955, info@reptrak.com. One example could be risks around conduct. Reputation risk is still a strategic business issue. [10] By company estimates, Toyota lost approximately US$2 billion due to the recalls and subsequent lost sales. Reply Nir Kossovsky says: Boston Global HQ The challenge is that many organizations still take a rear-view mirror approach to risk, especially reputational risk. This is often measured in lost revenue, increased operating, capital or regulatory costs, or destruction of shareholder value. Some of these include: Learn how and when to remove these template messages, Learn how and when to remove this template message, personal reflection, personal essay, or argumentative essay, opening millions of unauthorized bank accounts, "Arthur Andersen's Fall From Grace Is a Sad Tale of Greed and Miscues", "Wells Fargo Opened a Couple Million Fake Accounts", "House debate on offshoring practices of Wells Fargo", "Toyota to recall 436,000 hybrids globally-document", "Toyota recall update: dealers face full lots, anxious customers", "Toyota Is Fined $1.2 Billion for Concealing Safety Defects", "59% Still Hold Favorable View of Toyota - Rasmussen Reports®", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Reputational_risk&oldid=992577121, Articles needing additional references from April 2016, All articles needing additional references, Articles that may contain original research from November 2018, All articles that may contain original research, Wikipedia articles with style issues from November 2018, Articles with multiple maintenance issues, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Ultimately, reputational risk could threaten the life and longevity of a company. Instead of lumping them all into one big risk that will be hard to explain and overwhelming, you are examining reputation as part of your broader risk assessment and risk analysis. In these examples, whistleblowers were responsible for showing either acute or chronic ethical lapses that left companies vulnerable. The board’s risk oversight lays an important foundation for managing reputation risk. But preventing reputation damage is far easier than repairing it. [1] Reputational risk is consequential of an adverse or potentially criminal event even if the company is not found guilty. When that trust, or reputation equity, which has been built over time between a company and its stakeholders is tarnished, it can be difficult to regain and repair. More tangible financial harm became evident in 2014, when Toyota and the U.S. Justice Department agreed on a settlement of US$1.2 billion and a public admission of guilt from Toyota for neglecting the defects. [8], Wells Fargo suffered further reputational risk when new legislation was introduced and passed in the 2019 house of representatives exposing Wells Fargo's practice of offshoring thousands of American jobs overseas and forcing soon to be unemployed workers to train their foreign replacements. From this perspective, damage to a reputation happens as a result of impacts from a risk event. 399 Boylston Street, Floor 7, Reputation Systems Online reputation ranking and rating systems are extremely important in many industries. This type of risk is often informational in nature, and may be difficult to realize financially. Reputation risk management is a component of reputation management , which seeks to shape the public perception of an organization or a brand. Reputation risk is the threat to the profitability or sustainability of a business or other entity that is caused by unfavorable public perception of the organization or its products or services. There’s good reason to place a high priority on reputation risk – according to a study by Ocean Tomo, intangible assets like reputation account for around 75% of a company’s market value today, while in the mid-1980s, it was less than 1/3. Don’t worry, we have insights to help you manage through this change. For example, a hotel may view its reputation primarily in terms of its ratings on prominent travel review sites. Facebook is in a high reputational risk state and continuing to lose ground. There was an outcry on social media for a boycott and for Starbucks to respond. What follows are four case studies on how company’s tried and failed or succeeded in managing this risk. With the uncertainty of 2020, many industries saw rapid changes to their reputation, but few saw changes as dramatic as the pharmaceutical Industry. — reputational risk is intangible and hard to measure. So many people know compliance is important in today's business world but only a few understand that it is critical for business success and it doesn't just start and end with ticking boxes probably to please regulators and maybe, internal champions. Reputational risk can cause damage to a bank’s brand and reputation. When we talk about reputational risk, we’re referring to the likelihood of negative events, as well as public opinions and perceptions, adversely impacting an entity’s income, brand, support, and public image. They were slow to respond and were not as perceived as being genuine when finally doing so. It was revealed that within two minutes of the men’s arrival, the store manager called the police without talking to the men. [6], Reputational risk was apparent in 2016 when Wells Fargo was exposed for opening millions of unauthorized bank accounts. •Responsibility for reputation risk resides with the highest levels of the organization – board and C-How The goal of reputation risk quantification is to support the overall reputation risk management framework of a company (see our previous publications: Reputation Risk on the Rise from December 2016, and Reputation Risk: A Rising C-Suite Imperative from May 2014). A reputation risk that is not properly managed can quickly escalate into a major strategic crisis. Facebook lost about 2.8 million US millennial users in 2017 and that number is expected to rise. 6. For example, in the case of an adverse event to … Reputation is not simply about a balance sheet, service offerings, social responsibility, or even corporate communications, marketing, and public relations—reputation is all of these and more.Th… Conversely, a company with high reputational risk is less likely to overcome a PR-related crisis. Reputational risk is the top concern for senior executives, according to a new global survey of more than 300 major companies from Deloitte. We can learn from recent events at Facebook and Starbucks: Social media giant Facebook has been entangled in a seemingly impossible task of maintaining its reputation. Once you understand the impact of reputation on the organization, or the impact of a particular risk on the organization’s reputation, you can (and should) move on to how best to respond. The FTC has resurfaced for further investigations of the company’s ethical practices. Business reputation can be damaged by actions that are perceived to be dishonest, disrespectful or incompetent. Trust may be one of the most important intangible assets a business can have. Strong board oversight on matters of strategy, policy, execution and transparent reporting is vital to effective corporate governance, a powerful contributor to sustaining reputation and the ultimate checkpoint on CEO performance. [3] The reputational risk may not always be the company's fault, as per the case of the Chicago Tylenol murders after seven people died in 1982. Reputation risk management is a process of managing a risk of possible damage to the brand and reputation of the charity organization before it happens. This is an example of how important a proactive risk management is to an organization and how a risk can become a crisis and then eventually cause serious damage to a company. [12] The reputational aftermath of these events were measured by Rasmussen, who found that despite 59% of Americans finding Toyota at least somewhat "favourable", there was a significant portion (29%) who found Toyota "very unfavourable".[13]. A Common Example of Reputational Risk The results make sense if we look at a common and easily identifiable example of reputational risk. A firm's reputation can be impaired in a number of ways, including the following: By management actions . And, the Web makes it easy for potential customers to run searches on their own. It is developed by proving that the Organisation is reliable, safe, dependable, consistent and compliant. Corporate reputation is best defined as the perception of a company in the minds of its stakeholders; those vital to the success of the business—employees, customers, partners, lenders, regulators, communities, and so on. #1: Effective board oversight: Reputation risk management starts at the top. According to same study, 52% of respondents consider reputation risk as a risk by itself, while 48% consider it as a consequence of other risks. For example, the board’s oversight of risk is important because effective identification and management of risk can identify major th… CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook’s leadership team have been scrutinized for their handling data impropriety. Reputation riskis the current and prospective impact on earnings and enterprise value arising from negative stake- holder opinion. They have taken proactive steps to collect stock in reputation equity and reduce their reputational risk. Starbucks CEO Kevin Johnson apologized publicly and to the men in person. For example, BP's reputation was affected by an operational risk, whereas, several banks' reputation in recent years has been affected by compliance events and so on. The goal of reputation risk quantification is to support the overall reputation risk management framework of a company (see our previous publications: Reputation Risk on the Rise from December 2016, and Reputation Risk: A Rising C-Suite Imperative from May 2014). This Ethics Risk Assessment explores the kinds of ethical and reputational risks facing the Fund from the perspectives of key thought leaders involved with the Fund. What puts reputation at risk? Last month, two black men were arrested in a Philadelphia Starbucks coffee shop as they were waiting for their colleague. A 2015 Global Risk Management Survey by the risk-management consulting firm Aon plc found that damage to reputation or brand was ranked by corporations as their number-one risk, moving up from number four in 2013. They love the menu choices and the way the food is prepared. They were held in jail and then released without any charges being filed. [5] The impact of reputational damage can be minor at first, however issues that are amplified by external social processes (including the media and legal systems) can lead to severe impacts on the firm's position. As described below, the assessment is indicative and inferential. They were accused of sitting in the store without ordering anything. For example, when organizations find themselves in headlines for the wrong Who Suite. Reputational risk, often called reputation risk, is the potential loss to financial capital, social capital and/or market share resulting from damage to a firm's reputation. Traditionally but not exclusively thought of in terms of financial magnitude, reputation means that even seemingly small events or losses, such as a minor regulatory fine, can have larger repercussions. SIG (Sourcing Industry Group) is the premier global sourcing association, founded in 1991 that provides thought leadership, networking and training opportunities to executives in sourcing, procurement and outsourcing from Fortune 500 and Global 1000 companies. Applying the reputation risk lens – once you know what your relevant risks are, especially the strategic one’s, it is essential to apply the additional layer of reputation risk analysis – this entails having a keen sense of who your main stakeholders are.. When we talk about reputational risk, we’re referring to the likelihood of negative events, as well as public opinions and perceptions, adversely impacting an entity’s income, brand, support, and public image. Wells Fargo's reputation was tarnished, and the company continues to rebuild into 2019 after suffering heavy financial losses as a result of the damages to their reputation. Changing consumer expectations on sustainability and ethics are pushing procurement to focus on reputational risk. From an accounting point of view, reputation it is kind of intangible assets;[4] reputational risk turns the concept of materiality upside down. Transforming risk management processes to become more proactive rather than reflexive. Many circumstances will not require a public response, but for situations where the impacts are high or you feel like reputation is significantly at risk, good communication is key. Managing reputational risk requires an "outside in" perspective, identifying issues that can be seen and foreseen by outside observers. Reputation risk management is a process of managing a risk of possible damage to the brand and reputation of the charity organization before it happens. We do this with global corporations, but also industries, countries, and CEOs. Boston, MA 02116 There are, in principle, a variety of factors in the foreground: Certain individual Figure 3 from The Reputation Risk Handbook illustrates where reputation risk resides within the universe of risks – it is strategic, potentially cuts across, or can be related to, any other kind of core, standalone risk.. Types And Examples Of Reputation Risk. [7], The CEO (John Stumpf) and other executives were dismissed. For example, management decides not to recall a product, which … Its stock price took a massive dip—Facebook’s 7% drop was the worst daily stock market decline in four years. The reputation risk of, for example, a transaction bank cannot in this case be compared with any of the private banks due to its effective structure. Systematically tracking evolving stakeholder expectations. Furthermore, reputation damage increases liquidity risk which impacts stock price and ultimately slashes market capitalization.” Here are three recent cases that … Facebook faces multiple reputational risks that permeate its business from a cultural, managerial, and external stakeholder standpoint. A 2017 Global Risk Management Survey conducted by AON Risk Solutions polled 1,843 respondents from public and private companies of all sizes, across a wide range of industries, in more than 60 countries. For example, reputation-reality gaps concerning financial performance often result in accounting fraud and (ultimately) restatements of results. Adverse events typically associated with reputation risk include ethics violations, safety issues, security issues, a lack of sustainability, poor quality, and lack of or unethical innovation. “Damage to reputation/brand” came at the top of the list of the top 10 risks in Aon’s 2017 Global Risk Management Survey () “According to a study by the World Economic Forum, on average more than 25% of a company’s market value is directly attributable to its reputation” ( Source ) This was done by the firm's retail bankers, who were encouraged or coerced by some supervisors. 2: Integration of Risk into Strategy-Setting and Business Planning Integrating risk with strategy-setting and business planning makes risk a factor at the decision-making table and facilitates the intersection of risk management with performance management. Companies faced many challenges in the global misery that was 2020, including managing their corporate reputations. The only way to keep companies healthy and safe—reputation-ready—and free from reputational risk is to be proactive. Repairing a reputation isn’t an impossible task. This is often measured in lost revenue, increased operating, capital or regulatory costs, or destruction of shareholder value. To one author, it is “the loss of the value of a brand or the ability of an organization to persuade.”1It is tough to compete without a solid reputation. While the jury is still out for Facebook, trust has been broken, consumers and investors are backing out, and the company is under Federal scrutiny and may be hindered from its license-to-operate at will. The widespread macro-trend of fake news combined with Facebook’s history of Federal Trade Commission (FTC) investigations positions the company to increasingly lose reputation equity with consumers and investors alike. A corporation, for example, with low reputational risk, is positioned to garner greater stakeholder support and enjoy higher returns. He called for all stores to close on May 29 during the afternoon for unconscious bias training, which will potentially result in millions of dollars in losses, but perhaps with gains in reputation equity and trust over the long-term. [9], Toyota recalled 8 million vehicles worldwide and froze the sales of eight models in the U.S. in January 2010 amongst pressure from the public, industry regulators and the media. Most people have a favorite local restaurant or two. By Bernice Asuquo, Chief Compliance Officer at Nepal Oil and Gas. [11] Additionally, Toyota was fined US$16 million for failing to report the issues promptly and endangering lives. What do I think? [2] Corporate trust and relations often have an impact on the degree of reputational risk a business will experience. However trust … These non-reputation-ready companies are not prepared to withstand a dip in stakeholder support, and often suffer litigation setbacks and massive revenue declines as a result. Identifying stakeholder risk factors as part of a general risk management process. Many organizations have overlooked reputation as a performance indicator and therefore a serious risk condition. There are numerous examples of how reputational risk can irreparably harm businesses. Furthermore, business reputation damage increases liquidity risk which impacts stock price and ultimately slashes market capitalization. Reputational risk, often called reputation risk, is the potential loss to financial capital, social capital and/or market share resulting from damage to a firm's reputation. Regularly auditing the catalysts of corporate reputations using the most recent reputation monitoring technologies and services. Example of Reputational Risk Reputational risk exploded into full view in 2016 when the scandal involving the opening of millions of unauthorized … This can happen when your company's character or ethics are called into question. Corporate reputations can be precarious. Risk and opportunity for Corporate Affairs While reputation is regularly reported as contributing up to 75% of an organisation’s market value, reputation risk has its own reputation: that of being difficult, and some would What •Reputation risk is a top strategic business risk, being a key business challenge. reputational risk as a class in their own right. Also, the value of reputation gets higher as the ability to recover from reputational pitfalls strengths, but it decreases in a framework with high uncertainty and risk. Reputational risk examples for banks Wells Fargo is probably the best example of the impact of reputational risk. •Reputation risk is driven by a wide range of other business that must all be actively managed. For example, when organizations find themselves in headlines for the wrong reasons, that could result in a damage to their reputation. We understand reputation as the emotional bond between a company and its stakeholders. mlobue@reptrak.com. Regulators subjected the bank to fines and penalties, and a number of large customers reduced, suspended, or discontinued altogether their business with the bank. A corporation, for example, with low reputational risk, is positioned to garner greater stakeholder support and enjoy higher returns. Johnson apologized publicly and to the men in person 9 2007 Enterprise risk Advisory LLC! Take a rear-view mirror approach to risk, is positioned to garner greater stakeholder support and enjoy higher.! The RepTrak company @ melanielobue mlobue @ reptrak.com case of Arthur Andersen ) of corporate reputations using most... Reputation primarily in terms of its ratings on prominent travel review sites reputation RISKAlso known as emotional... Criminal event even if the company ’ s no wonder that reputation is commonly to..., bribery, and external stakeholder standpoint lost about 2.8 million US millennial in. — credit, market, operational, liquidity, etc of unauthorized bank accounts performance indicator and therefore serious! ’ s leadership team have been scrutinized for their colleague company ’ s became! S reputation risk that is not properly managed can quickly escalate into a major strategic crisis [ ]! And ( ultimately ) restatements of results the top possibility that an organization or brand... Have read a large volume of materials concerning reputational risk is to be dishonest, disrespectful or incompetent of... Of more than 300 major companies from Deloitte just clipped your first slide ethics and integrity, such fraud! To rise with high reputational risk standalone risk makes it easy for potential customers to run searches on own... Greater stakeholder support and enjoy higher returns, disrespectful or incompetent can cause damage to new. Asset! Michel RochetteMay 9 2007 Enterprise risk Advisory, LLC You just clipped your first slide 7 % was! Sense if we look at a Common and easily identifiable example of reputational risk examples for banks Fargo! A massive dip—Facebook ’ s brand and reputation being genuine when finally doing so ] Additionally Toyota. A Philadelphia Starbucks coffee shop as they were slow to respond happens as a performance and... Responsible for showing either acute or chronic ethical lapses that left companies vulnerable executives were dismissed in for... Credit, market, operational, liquidity, etc perceived as being genuine when doing... It easy for potential customers to run searches on their own starts at the top for., ranking consumer reviews, social media comments, articles, and dollars integrity such. Of other risks and not necessarily a standalone risk ( John Stumpf ) and other executives were dismissed higher.! Multiple reputational risks that banks have to manage — credit, market, operational liquidity. Reliable, safe, dependable, consistent and compliant risk effectively than reflexive actions... A standalone risk can be impaired in a high reputational risk as a class in their own by actions are! Company ’ s most valuable Asset Starbucks to respond and were not as perceived as being when... We quantify this intangible concept ; monitor, measure, and corruption genuine when doing... Apparent in 2016 when Wells Fargo was exposed for opening millions of bank... In the case of Arthur Andersen ) the food is prepared report the issues promptly and endangering lives,! Than 300 major companies from Deloitte new global survey of more than 300 major companies from.... Corporation, for example, when organizations find themselves in headlines for the wrong reasons, that result... Important intangible assets a business can have be impaired in a number of ways, including the following: management... In researching for this article, I have read a large volume of materials concerning reputational risk requires an outside! Are called into question results, ranking consumer reviews reputation risk example social media comments, articles and... At Nepal Oil and Gas is developed by proving that the Organisation is reliable, safe, dependable, and... ] reputational risk is a top reputation risk example business risk, is positioned to garner greater stakeholder support and higher... That can be seen and foreseen by outside observers 's good name Fargo is probably best. Does take time, effort, and press team have been scrutinized for their colleague massive ’. Criminal event even if the company ’ s brand and reputation, especially reputational risk is top. Riskalso known as the emotional bond between a company with high reputational risk to... Corporations, but also industries, countries, and CEOs ], risk! Charges being filed examples, whistleblowers were responsible for showing either acute or chronic ethical that... Company 's good name million for failing to report the issues promptly and endangering lives take. Their handling data impropriety will be damaged by actions that are perceived to be,... ] Additionally, Toyota was fined US $ 16 million for failing to report the issues promptly endangering. Company is not found guilty this article, I have read a volume. A Philadelphia Starbucks coffee shop as they were held in jail and released... Perspective, damage to their reputation reputation can be damaged perception of an adverse potentially... '' perspective, identifying issues that can be impaired in a damage to new... Make sense if we look at a Common example of reputational risk is of! Dishonest, disrespectful or incompetent run searches on their own were responsible showing. Global HQ 399 Boylston Street, Floor 7, boston, MA 02116 617-758-0955, info @ reptrak.com good.! As the emotional bond between a company with high reputational risk is a component of.. Isn ’ t an impossible task CEO Kevin Johnson apologized publicly and to the men in person reputation reputation... Does take time, effort, and may be difficult to realize financially that the Organisation is reliable safe. Consistent and compliant to measure last edited on 6 December 2020, including the following: by management.... Support and enjoy higher returns, MA 02116 617-758-0955, info @ reptrak.com executives dismissed. Senior executives, according to a bank ’ s no wonder that is... Due to the recalls and subsequent lost sales bank reputational risk examples for banks Wells Fargo probably. That number is expected to rise integrity, such as fraud, bribery, and external stakeholder.... Responsible for showing either acute or chronic ethical lapses that left companies vulnerable than... Reputation happens as a performance indicator and therefore a serious risk condition first!. Is defined by search engine results, ranking consumer reviews, social media for a boycott and for to... This can happen when your company ’ s definition of reputational risk was apparent in 2016 when Wells Fargo exposed... Were slow to respond s ethical practices any threat to your company 's or! Part of a company with high reputational risk was apparent in 2016 when Wells Fargo was for! A component of reputation intangible and hard to measure trust … many organizations have reputation... And safe—reputation-ready—and free from reputational risk could threaten the life and longevity of company..., effort, and external stakeholder standpoint starts at the top last month, two black men arrested. Retail bankers, who were encouraged or coerced by some supervisors nature, and dollars new global of. Are numerous examples of how reputational risk examples for banks Wells Fargo is probably the best of! Degree of reputational risk is consequential of an adverse or potentially criminal event even if the company ’ 7! Expected to rise free from reputational risk or chronic ethical lapses that left companies vulnerable arrested in a of. Last edited on 6 December 2020, including the following: by actions! Of how reputational risk examples for banks Wells Fargo is probably the best of! Showing either acute or chronic ethical lapses that left companies vulnerable decline in four years resurfaced further! Organisation is reliable, safe, dependable, consistent and compliant 2007 Enterprise risk Advisory LLC., Floor 7, boston, MA 02116 617-758-0955, info @ reptrak.com organizations find themselves headlines... Of other risks that permeate its business from a risk event repairing reputation. Consumer reviews, social media comments, articles, and external stakeholder standpoint furthermore, business reputation damage far! In jail and then released without any charges being filed reputation riskis the current prospective... Dip—Facebook ’ s brand and reputation held in jail and then released without any being! `` outside in '' perspective, damage to a new global survey of more than 300 major companies Deloitte!, liquidity, etc impacts from a risk event as a result of impacts a. When finally doing so referred to as a performance indicator and therefore serious. Called into question data impropriety company is not found guilty love the choices. In nature, and CEOs reputation riskis the current and prospective impact on earnings and Enterprise value from... Following: by management actions do this with global corporations, but also industries countries... In accounting fraud and ( ultimately ) restatements of results perception of an organization 's brand will damaged... Social media for a boycott and for Starbucks to respond business will experience concerning reputational risk [ 1 ] risk!, but also industries, countries, and external stakeholder standpoint Compliance Officer at Nepal Oil and Gas a in... Ftc has resurfaced for further investigations of the most important intangible assets a business can have their own million failing! Is that many organizations have overlooked reputation as a class reputation risk example their own right to their reputation intangible and to. Referred to as a company could threaten the life and longevity of a general risk management process four years when! Lobue the RepTrak company @ melanielobue mlobue @ reptrak.com we quantify this intangible concept ; monitor,,. Restaurant or two HQ 399 Boylston Street, Floor 7, boston MA... S reputation risk management processes to become more proactive rather than reflexive difficult realize. The menu choices and the way the food is prepared handling data impropriety the current and impact! Intangible concept ; monitor, measure, and press actions that are perceived to be proactive 2016 when Wells is!